Ethical Considerations in Total Joint Arthroplasty.

J Am Acad Orthop Surg · Oct 01 2023 · Review

Tarwala R, Mercuri JJ, Iorio R, Karkare N

From the Donald and Barbara Zucker School of Medicine at Hofstra/Northwell, Lenox Hill Hospital, New York, NY (Karkare)

Adult Reconstruction

SUMMARY — THE REDUCTIONReview of ethical issues in hip and knee arthroplasty, including industry influence, new technology adoption, direct-to-consumer implant marketing, cost-sharing and bundled payments, access to care, and resident education.
Abstract, as published

Hip and knee arthroplasty surgeries have excellent outcomes and notably improve quality of life. However, ethical issues permeate the practice of adult reconstruction, and as economics and technology evolve, these issues have become increasingly important. This article will review the currently published literature on ethical issues including industry influences, implants and instrumentations, surgical innovation, new technology adoptions, and healthcare policy-relevant issues, including patient cost sharing and bundled care programs. In addition, the direct marketing of implants from the manufacturer to the general public may falsely raise patient expectations concerning the long-term clinical outcome and performance of newer devices in the absence of long-term studies. This article will also focus on relevant contemporary ethical issues that do not necessarily have preexisting published literature or guidelines but, nonetheless, are crucial for adult reconstruction surgeons to address. These issues include access to care and challenges with orthopaedic resident and fellow education. Surgeons must understand the ethical issues that can arise in their clinical practice and how those issues affect patients. Clinicians are tasked with making the best-reasoned judgment possible to optimize their patients' outcomes. Still, the ability to standardize treatment while optimizing individual outcomes for unique patients remains a challenge.

Featured in the 2026-10-02 issue.

← Current Concepts in Alignment in Total Knee Arthroplasty.Total Knee Arthroplasty →

The Reduction is a free email digest of newly published orthopaedic literature — a handful of new papers in the subspecialties you choose, each summarized like this one. Subscribe free or browse the archive.