One- vs. Two-Stage Exchange for Chronic Hip Periprosthetic Joint Infection: A Framework Based on Patient Treatment Burden and Institutional Capability.

JBJS Rev · Aug 01 2026 · Review

Ference DA, Carrier RE, Capote GN, Scheinberg DS, Hernandez VH, D'Apuzzo MR, et al.

Department of Orthopedic Surgery, University of Miami Miller School of Medicine, Miami, Florida

Adult Reconstruction

SUMMARY — THE REDUCTIONThis review argues that choosing between one- and two-stage exchange for chronic hip PJI should weigh patient treatment burden and institutional protocol capability rather than relying solely on traditional selection criteria, given comparable infection-eradication rates at experienced centers.
Abstract, as published

» Recent evidence demonstrates equivalent infection-eradication rates between one-stage revision (OSR) and two-stage revision (TSR) in chronic hip periprosthetic infection at experienced centers. » The decision between OSR and TSR should account for patient treatment burden, which includes functional limitation, spacer complications, medical morbidity, psychological burden, and cost. » Traditional OSR selection criteria may identify patients with greater overall surgical complexity rather than reliably unfavorably biasing reinfection risk. » Standardized institutional protocols are critical for the success of OSR and include careful patient selection, microbiologic planning, thorough debridement, clean-phase separation and dual setup, experience with complex hip revision surgery, and multidisciplinary coordination. » TSR remains appropriate in clinical scenarios involving fungal infection, substantial host compromise, prior failed septic revision, and at institutions where highly specific and standardized protocols cannot be reliably implemented.

Featured in the 2026-09-05 issue.

← Integrating Smartphone Applications and Wearable Devices for …Irrigation Solutions and Antibiotic Powders: Should I Use The… →

The Reduction is a free email digest of newly published orthopaedic literature — a handful of new papers in the subspecialties you choose, each summarized like this one. Subscribe free or browse the archive.